Rights and Bureaucracy · News · 🇧🇷 Brazil
Habeas corpus written only with AI and a letter from the STJ to the OAB
An STJ justice sent a letter to the OAB over a habeas corpus petition with AI-fabricated citations and no original argument.
- Profession
- Lawyer
- Tools
- IA generativa
- Source
- migalhas.com.br ↗
- Country
- 🇧🇷 Brazil
- Report date
- May 20, 2026
- Verified on
- October 24, 2026
What they did
The filing had eleven sections with case-law citations unrelated to the case, some of them fabricated.
How it went
Justice Rogerio Schietti denied the injunction and notified the OAB, stating that the lawyer did not write a single sentence of original argument. The account gives no numbers.
Good to know
Besides fines, there is disciplinary risk. Use AI to structure ideas, not to replace your own argumentation.
The prompt
I'm a lawyer. Based on the facts [summary without names], propose an outline of arguments in bullet points, indicating where I need to look for real precedents. Do not cite case law.
Replace what is in [brackets]. Prompt written by us from the account, not a literal copy of the source. Do not paste other people’s personal data (privacy laws such as LGPD and GDPR apply).
Summary in our own words. Results as stated in the original account; we have not tested or audited them. Read the source ↗ Found a mistake?
Similar cases
01Lawyer Fined by the TSE for Case Law Invented by AI
A TSE justice fined a lawyer and notified the OAB after nonexistent citations created with AI.
02When the "Rapporteur" Cited by AI Was a Bar Owner
A judge in Concórdia (SC) discovered that the rapporteur of a ruling cited in a filing was actually a bar owner.
03Case Law Invented by AI and the Fine of Ten Minimum Wages
A lawyer from Juazeiro (BA) was fined over a filing with fake rulings generated by AI and blamed the document on an intern.
04What happens when AI invents case law (TJSC)
A court fined a party who filed an appeal with nonexistent rulings and legal scholarship generated by AI.
05Resolving a Consumer Dispute with the Help of AI
An engineer from Rio Claro (SP) used AI to resolve a defective laptop and later built a free consumer protection tool.
06The ChatGPT-written petition that earned a fine from the TSE
A lawyer filed a petition written with ChatGPT at the TSE and was fined for bad-faith litigation.
07Disputing a denied flight delay compensation claim
The agent checked the flight data, concluded the airline's excuse didn't hold up under European rules and drafted the appeal.
08Registering a trademark in the US with an agent's help
An entrepreneur says Claude Cowork guided them through every step of the trademark application at the US patent office.